Color, 1959, 83 mins.
Directed by Terence Fisher
Starring Anton Diffring, Hazel Court, Christopher Lee, Arnold Marlé, Delphi Lawrence, Francis De Wolff
Vinegar Syndrome (UHD & Blu-ray) (US R0/RA 4K/HD), Eureka (Blu-ray & DVD) (UK RB/R2 HD/PAL), Legend Films (Blu-ray & DVD) (US RA/R1 HD/NTSC) / WS (1.66:1) (16:9)


Riding high in 1959 in the The Man Who Could Cheat Deathwake of Horror of Dracula and its first two Frankenstein films, Hammer Film Productions was tinkering with other The Man Who Could Cheat Deathproperties to adapt-- preferably with various combinations of its two biggest stars, Peter Cushing and Christopher Lee. The duo did team up for '59's The Mummy and The Hound of the Baskervilles, both solid classics from director Terence Fisher, but a third attempt that year with the same director and stars didn't prove so lucky. Intended to star Cushing in the main role, The Man Who Could Cheat Death was adapted by regular Hammer scribe Jimmy Sangster from the Barré Lyndon stage play The Man in Half Moon Street from 1939, previously filmed in 1945 for the big screen and adapted for British television (now lost) starring Anton Diffring. Essentially a blend of Dorian Gray and Dr. Jekyll / Mr. Hyde, the source material was light on gruesome material but had enough monstrous potential to fit the Hammer template. However, Cushing declined to do the film less than a week before shooting started, leaving Hammer to fill the role with Diffring instead (just before his iconic role in Circus of Horrors) to the annoyance of distributor Paramount. Though undeniably the work of Fisher and the usual brilliant team members like cinematographer Jack Asher and makeup artist Roy Ashton, The Man Who Could Cheat Death was treated like a disposable programmer at the time and stubbornly refused to turn up on home video for decades (with TV airings being few and far between as well). In more recent years it has undergone significant reappraisal The Man Who Could Cheat Deathwith fans enjoying the film for what it is rather than what could have been, essentially pointing the way to another frequently sidelined Fisher drawing room chiller, The Man Who Could Cheat Death1960's The Two Faces of Dr. Jekyll.

A fixture in Parisian high society near the end of the 19th century, physician and sculptor Dr. Georges Bonnet hides a remarkable secret. Thanks to the breakthrough gland treatments of the seemingly much older Professor Weiss (Marlé), Bonnet has reached the age of 104 via a transplant process every ten years. However, his latest treatment has been unavoidably delayed with means he has to stave off the aging process with a temporary green potion treatment four times a day. Bonnet also occasionally attacks anyone who stumbles across his secret, with his latest crime investigated by Inspector LeGris (de Wolff) which pulls his former flame Janine (Court) and friend Dr. Pierre Gerrard (Lee, who repeated the same character name in Hammer's Scream of Fear) into the bizarre cover-up. In fact, Bonnet now plans to use Pierre as his new surgeon of choice to keep him alive now that Weiss has been debilitated, but of course, nothing plays out as planned.

Though its stage-bound origins are still very apparent, The Man Who Could Cheat Death benefits greatly from that Fisher touch with a beautiful, burnished Technicolor look that tended to get lost in inferior presentations. Diffring is actually quite solid in the role with his chilly reserve giving Bonnet an almost inhuman quality, and of course it's always good to see Court and Lee teaming up again after The Curse of Frankenstein. Like several other Hammer titles, this was the subject of much speculation about alternate, stronger footage shot for markets in France or Japan -- which in this case turned out to be true, with the producers paying The Man Who Could Cheat DeathCourt an additional fee to do an alternate topless scene while posing for a sculpture. The BBFC also insisted on some brief cuts to the fiery climax, namely reducing some trauma and screaming during the pandemonium but nothing as extreme as the The Man Who Could Cheat Deathextended Horror of Dracula ending.

The first U.S. home video release of the film arrived in 2008 on DVD from Legend Films, later upgraded to a "spine-tingling double feature" on Blu-ray from the same label in 2011 paired up with The Skull. The same transfer was used for a U.K. special edition from Eureka on Blu-ray and DVD in 2015 which added interviews with Kim Newman (17m9s) and Jonathan Rigby (16m52s) about the making of the film and its place in the Hammer canon.

In 2025, Vinegar Syndrome revisited the film as a tremendously upgraded special edition UHD and Blu-ray set featuring two versions of the film: the U.K. one and a restoration of the pre-censored "Continental" one, once thought lost, featuring the Court nude scene (which is way more lingering than expected). Either way you also get the original uncensored version of the finale with more trauma and screaming. (The running times are identical at 83 minutes on the dot.) This is one case where you absolutely should go for the UHD if possible, as the HDR10-compatible Dolby Vision grading brings out some gorgeous colorful touches you really can't appreciate otherwise. Hammer titles in general rely on color schemes a great deal for their effectiveness (as much as any MGM musical or Disney film, really), and this presentation exceeds anything you'd see even in a theatrical print. It's also worth noting that this transfer preserves the original day for night color timing (see the fifth frame grab comparison below) with a spooky blue hue rather than the drab gray on the earlier disc releases. The DTS-HD MA 2.0 English mono track also sounds immaculate and comes with English SDH subtitles.

A new audio commentary The Man Who Could Cheat Deathwith Newman and Stephen Jones is as fun as you would hope as they cover the history of the play and its earlier screen The Man Who Could Cheat Deathversion (including the acid bath missing from this one), the whole Cushing casting mess, the state of Hammer at the time, and all of the genre connections running throughout this tale. In "The Man Who Can Chat Death" (7m25s), uncredited third assistant director Hugh Harlow talks about his time on the film, the enjoyable process of working with the cast, his positive impressions of the result, and his admiration for Fisher's directorial style and Asher's lighting. In "Court in Session" (17m8s), Melanie Williams looks at the life and career of Hazel Court including the impact Curse had on her career, the opportunities horror presented to her as a thespian (including her work for Roger Corman), and the breadth of her output including British television. In "The Man Who Could Direct Death" (24m32s), Vic Pratt chronicles the history of Terence Fisher's ascension through the film business after growing up during the silent era and his efficiency that made him a reliable professional to fit the demands of Hammer's working methods. Then you get a new, different Rigby interview "A Hideous Concoction" (26m42s), covering the sudden interest in major studios like Columbia and Paramount in teaming up with Hammer, the history of the story at the studio, the rejuvenation theme present in multiple Michael Carreras production, and social fads at the time that tie in with this and other Hammers around that time. Finally you get the one-minute censored ending if you feel like comparing, and the elaborate, quite striking packaging comes with a 40-page book with essays by Adrian Smith ("Hammer Horror in the Rue Noire"), Jon Dear ("Cheated of Death - A Conceptual Hammer Horror"), and Kieran Foster ("James Carreras: The Man Who Could Charm Hollywood"), which are all solid but tricky to read being dark red text on black paper. Definitely a must for any devoted or casual Hammer fan.

Vinegar Syndrome (UHD)
The Man Who Could Cheat DeathThe Man Who Could Cheat DeathThe Man Who Could Cheat DeathThe Man Who Could Cheat Death The Man Who Could Cheat Death

Vinegar Syndrome (Blu-ray)
The Man Who Could Cheat DeathThe Man Who Could Cheat DeathThe Man Who Could Cheat DeathThe Man Who Could Cheat Death The Man Who Could Cheat Death

Eureka (Blu-ray)
The Man Who Could Cheat DeathThe Man Who Could Cheat DeathThe Man Who Could Cheat DeathThe Man Who Could Cheat Death The Man Who Could Cheat Death

Reviewed on November 3, 2025